From Maol Chean-Dearg

MG 3146

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1/125, f8, ISO 100 @ 17m

An Appreciation of Atlbeithe

The lovely Altbeithe Hostel, tucked away in the upper reaches of Glen Affric, saved my recent trip to the Highldands. Albeithe is in good health, and there are plans for development next year which should make this amazing place even more popular.

Albeithe Bothy in the Upper Reaches of Glen Affric

Albeithe Youth Hostel, Glen Affric

[Read more...]

A Meditation on Time and Distance

My forthcoming trip to Scotland is an eye-opener in many ways, not least because we will be using the car to jump from place, disturbing my minds existing ‘map’ of the Highlands.

Will I ever see the area in quite the same way again?

[Read more...]

The Bagging Itinerary

I thought some of you might like to see the itinerary that Carl (the mad bagger) and I will be taking next week.

First off, we will arrive in scotland after  abrief stop at the Perth/Broxden Travel Inn! We’ll, the tackle Beinn Liath Mor and Sgurr Ruadth, do a night of wild camping and then head on to Maol Chean-Dearg. Then, I see, we’ll be at the wonderful Cannich campsite — I’ll have to introduce carl to the pleasures of the Polish Bar.

Next, we’re off to the Mullardoch circuit which will also take in the Benula Hills just above Albeithe. Two days wild camping here.

Finally, we’re off to do a Loch Monar circuit of sorts which includes (I think) Tom a Choinich, Carn a Choire Bhoidheach, Sgurr Mor and Sgurr nan Conbhairean, with another wildcamp in the middle.

We seem to have two rest days, which seems a bit exessive to me. These seem to be spent at te Culloden vilsitor centre. Apparently it is good.

Oh, and two nights — if I can cope with it — at Colonnel Gerry’s Hostel in Craig.

You can’t say we are not ambitious! It should be a great trip. I will be taking the podcast gear.

None of it means much to me. But I’m sure the scenerary will look great! And also hoping the midges can be kept at bay. I remember midges giving me problems in cannich in May, goodness knows what they will be like in August!

Challenge Photographs 1

This year the combination of bad weather and very long days — I found myself a day behind schedule — meant that I only took about half of the number of photos that I usually do. Of those that I took a fair number were given aded atmosphere by rain splatters on the lens! Anyhow, the first processing of photos is always one of my first steps on ending a hike, so here isa first offering!

Feughside Rainbow

Rainbow over Feughside

From Beinn Resipol

From Beinn Resipol

Glen Gour

Glen Gour

Lower Feshie

Lower Glen Feshie

Towards Bealach Dubh

Towards the Bealach Dubh from Loch Ossian

Corrour Train

The evening train passes through Corrour

Monaliadth Moments

My posts on the wind turbine developments in the Highlands have elicited a load of replies many of which are quite detailed and will require some reading and thought. I’ll get around to doing this at the weekend, but first I thought I’d reflect on some of my own personal experiences in this magical place.

The Monaliadth is not an area that I know well but I have walked through it in 2009 and 2010 on my coast-to-coast walks across the highlands. My first thoughts on the area came when planning my first TGO Challenge five years ago. I looked at the land on the East side of Loch Ness. The map was empty save for brown contours and rather a lot of blue lines. To my untutored eye it seemed to be not only empty but wet. There were no great peaks here but as sure as hell there would be a lot of bogs. You wouldn’t be walking here unless you liked bashing through the heather. That year I strolled over the Corriarick Pass which touches on the area. I wasn’t particularly impressed with the pass. However, as I strolled over Scotland on this and the next event a number of people began to wax lytically about the place. Fans of the Monaliadth describe it in glowing tones, making it seem almost magical.

In 2009 I climbed up from Dumnaglass with a group of friends. The Monaliadth might not be the highest hills but the climb up is long and steep and constantly reminds you that your starting point had been from sea level at the side of Ness. I was feeling dreadful after having picked up some kind o bug (I returned to Birmingham to find the place in the grip of a swine flu outbreak). But the weather was gorgeous, the skies were aquamarine blue and highlighted with the occasional fluffy white cloud. As the track climbed higher some spectacular views started to unveil themselves and it seemed that there would be an extensive view from the top of the ridge. And yes, there were sights of the occasional wind turbine and they seemed to compliment the area and the skyline. But there weren’t that many of them; it was a bit like one of those nice brochures that you can find. Colin Ibbotson, who was walking with me, told me that he’d never had bad weather in the Monaliadth. Surely that can’t have been right? Nope. The weather was always good.

 

Steve Smith

We lunched at a shooting hit at the end of the long path. This is a well maintained hut and thought he windows are blocked out the doors were kept open as a place of refuge for walkers. For us the hut provided welcome shade from the dramatic Scottish sun.

Monaliadth Foothills Monaliadth Mountains

Climbing on we followed the line of a small stream that had cut its way through the peaty landscape. The sky stayed blue. The terrain was all dazzling golds and ochres, greens and browns. We stumbled on mountain hares and in the distance saw birds of prey floating on the thermals.

My plan had been to turn at the top of the ridge and walk along it but in my feverish condition it seemed best to take a more direct route and we dropped down over the other side of the ridge and followed more streams as the headed down towards the Findhorn. By now there were four of us. We found a quiet place in the heather, a dry place next to the stream. Here we lay down in the sun and dozed. We took off our shoes and socks and tangled our feet in the crisp and razor clear water. There may not have been any of the drama of the North West here but in that sun, in the middle of the bog, it seemed as if we had reached paradise.

Bogs ...

Eventually we descended to the Findhorn itself. Colin and Shirley wanted to push on but I was whacked. Kate and I pitched our tent on a spit of land that stretched out into the water and led us well away from the path. It was early evening now and the gentle quality of the light seemed to reflect the tobaccos and pinks of the natural landscape. The Findhorn itself was gentle and mellow. Startling beams of light shone on the water and reflected back off both tiny stones and ripples of water. Could there have been any better place to lie and come to terms with a bug?

In the evening sun I found myself thinking of my mate Pete Arnold who had recently become involved with the Findhorn community, a new age grouping who were creating their idea settlement and community where the Findhorn reached the sea. The community treat the river as a spirit and the highlights of Pete’s visits were treks up into the mountains to follow the river to its source. Lying on my mat and gazing out at the glen I could see the attraction even though there is precious new age about me.

River Findhorn

The next morning I was feeling a little better. We strolled down the river through Coignafearn. Here the biggest herd of deer I had ever seen were taking an early morning drink from the river. The bend in the river opposite seemed to be housing thousands of deer. From a distance they looked like flocks of birds. As we neared we could see a line of literally hundred of deer, already watered, taking to a higher ground in one perfect procession. We crossed the river and followed a stream up a narrow valley before branching out and following another tiny stream up through the peat. We rested at a tiny lochan at the top and then dropped down through the peat and heather to the River Dunaine, trotting alongside the river before taking the Burma Road up and over to Aviemore and the Cairngorms. As we descended we were edged on by the view of the Cairngorms shining in the sun, a gentle canopy of snow reflecting the suns from the tops. Magic.

I remember taking the Burma road with an overwhelming sense of loss. I’d be back and next time take a more prolonged stroll through this land. That night in the dodgy shack bar of the Hilton Hotel I discussed this with travel writer John Manning. He shared my enthusiasms. He told me that one of his ambitions was to take a pack full of provisions and to just spend the best part of a week ambling over the peat and the heather. I could see the point.

Last year I returned. Again I climbed up the path from Drumnaglass but this time without the aid of any swine flu. I left my lunch companions in the hut and continued to climb on the main ridge that runs from Carn Odhar and on to Carn Ghriogair. This time I reached the ridge and turned left to head for Ghriogair.

Underfoot the route was a nightmare. I dodged from peaty bog to peaty bog, following the rusty line of years old fence posts their fences having long disappeared. The going was slow. But the view, oh the views. To my right lay the wonder of the Cairngorms, the full chain of mountains laid out in a beautiful line that was parallel to my route. This time they were topped with even more snow. But to my left were the hills of the North West that I had long left behind. The skies were crisp and clear. I could see the hills at the top of Glen Affric that I had skirted just a few days before. I could literally see for miles, and miles and miles.

Carn Ghriogair is not much of a hill really but it proved to be a perfect vantage point to stop and take in the views. I sat against a summit stone and ate my sandwiches. Again the hares were darting too and fro. A sudden movement in the distance revealed a long line of deer on the move. They’d smelt me from a distance.

More Peat Bogs River Dunaine The Burma Road

I was headed for Glen Mazaran. I dropped down North East of the summit to pick up a tiny stream that cut its way through the peat. Following this down it quickly became a fast running river. I turned a corner and headed East and was rewarded by a stunning view of Glen Mazaran. This may not be one of the biggest glens in the area but it is picture perfect. Near a bridge I rendezvoused with Phil Turner, Lee Well, Tony Bow and Ian Cotterill. Here again was that wonderful golden evening light. And the waters of Mazaran were just as refreshing as those of the Findhorn.

Next morning Phil and I set off early down the valley to meet the Findhorn. As we continued downstream we quickly began to loose the hills and the wild land. But we turned South and climbed high onto the moor again. A gillie engaged us in conversation to warn us that the grouse chicks were about to hatch. but the huts were open he said and he would be pleased if we used them. And they were very fine huts.

From the summit of Carn Dubh we descended into our last unspoilt stretch of peat and bog before reaching the Dunaine and the Burma Road.

Life was immeasurably better for having taken the time for an extended stroll through the Monaliadth. It is indeed a magical place, a space in which to recharge the batteries and uplift the spirit.

A few days ago I studies the Drumglass windfarm plans on Alan Sloman’s blog. My walk up to the ridge would be a walk up through turbines. The prominent view from my ridge would no longer be mountains but turbines. From Carn Ghriogair I could see a wind farm in the far off distance but one that was not slap bang in the middle of the wild land.

I rang Al up and we shared notes on our walking experiences. Al pointed out that if I could see all the hills of the NW from my ridge I’d be able to see the Drumnaglass windfarm from any one of those distant peaks! At that point the penny really dropped.

As I said yesterday if there was a road along that ridge there would be an outcry at the destruction of that view. The are wilder more lonley spots than this in the Highlands. But the Monaliadth is accessible from the resorts and bases of the Spey Valley and a quick look around the net will show you how well they are used.

I do not plan to go this way on this year’s TGO Challenge. But I must be back before the destruction starts.

i know of few more previous places to me.

 

Glen Mazaran

 Monaliadth Mountains

Monaliadth: John Muir Trust Objections

Further to my post yesterday, I thought you might be interested in the formal objection to the scheme from the John Muir Trust. Their arguments are balanced and reasoned and seems to get the balance about right.

 

 


The Scottish Executive,
Consents and Emergency Planning Unit, 
2nd Floor, 
Meridian Court, 
5 Cadogan Street, 
Glasgow 
G2 6AT

Dear Sir or Madam,

Renewable Energy Systems Limited:
Proposed windfarm development at Dunmaglass, Inverness.

The John Muir Trust wishes to lodge a formal objection to the revised planning application of Renewable Energy Systems Limited to develop a wind farm at Dunmaglass in the Monadhliath. Our objection relates to impacts on wildlife, wild land, cumulative impact and the implications for the local economy.  We objected to the original proposal and maintain an objection.

The Trust does not feel that the revision of the scheme – from thirty-six, 110m high turbines to thirty-three, 125m turbines addresses any of the major issues which such a large scheme in a sensitive site raises.  Although the SEI states that there is a significant reduction in the area of the wind farm, the increased height of the turbines means that the visual impact could be more damaging than the previous scheme.  The overview map, Map 2 of the non-technical summary, of tip height ZTV makes that clear.

The JMT supports the development of small-scale, sensitively sited renewable energy schemes, in areas adjacent to existing settlements, which demonstrate that renewable energy may be sourced without significantly impacting on “wild land” or wildlife. The JMT, while generally in support of the development of renewable energy systems, opposes new developments where they significantly threaten “wild land”.

The majority of proposals to develop renewable energy schemes in Scotland have, to an extent, avoided the most iconic areas of wild land. The Dunmaglass proposal is blatantly irresponsible in that regard.

The JMT opposes the proposed Dunmaglass because:

• There is a significant impact on “wild land”, 
• There is a significant threat to wildlife (especially designated habitats and species), 
• The scheme and its associated infrastructure are not sympathetically designed, 
• The scheme is considered to be of an excessive scale, 
• The cumulative impact with other wind developments, consented or in application, will be considerable.

The Monadhliath, an unsung mountain treasure of the Scottish Highlands, is caught between the dramatic steep sided peaks in the West Highlands and the high altitude frost shattered arctic plateaus of the Cairngorms. Because its beauty is hard to pigeonhole and define it has an enigmatic appeal, which is entirely unique from other areas of wild land in the UK.

The Highland Council Inverness Local Plan states: “The Monadhliath Mountains comprise arguably the largest contiguous tract of accessible mountain and moorland in the Highlands. The main policy thrust of these areas should be to value their natural and semi-natural features, encourage measures which improve or reinstate their biodiversity in key habitats and to presume against intrusive developments which would detract from their intrinsic core qualities.”

The Monadhliath are identified within Scottish Natural Heritage’s “search areas for wild land”.  Policies on wild land, SNH’s alongside JMT’s and others, demonstrate the growing awareness of the fragility of wild land and the need to ensure that it is adequately protected. Alongside other renewable energy schemes proposed and approved on the margins of the range, the Dunmaglass scheme is a step too far into this key area of wild land.

The scheme’s infrastructure would be highly visible and intrusive not only within the Monadhliath itself, but much further afield, including the neighbouring Cairngorms National Park. This has serious implications for the reputation of the area, which currently attracts a large proportion of its income from visitors wishing to enjoy the wildness of the mountain environment.

Given the location, a scheme of any scale would have serious implications for both wild land and wildlife; the proposal to erect thirty-three 125m turbines in this area implies a complete lack of respect for the landscape value and conservation interest of the area.

This proposal will result in unacceptable damage to a large area of relatively unspoilt upland peatland and significant disturbance to rare and protected species. In particular the anticipated death toll of the Golden Eagle is considered wholly unacceptable. Alongside the wild land and landscape issues, the threat to the many other protected species in the area simply cannot be justified.

The Supplementary Environmental Information states that there is “a definite trend in some areas towards clustering of wind farms” and seems to suggest this is desirable.  The John Muir Trust would oppose such a view and finds discussions about “one windfarm” or “two windfarms” unhelpful, rather than discussing actual numbers, sizes and impacts of turbines.

In the timescale given, the Trust has not managed to fully assess the SEI (having had no notice from the Energy Consents Unit despite our previous objection) and so this only represents the most obvious concerns.  We would expect the opportunity to give more detailed evidence at an appropriate time.

The John Muir Trust urges the Scottish Executive to reject this planning application.

Yours sincerely,

Helen McDade
Head of Policy

The John Muir Trust

A Chilly Wind Blows Through the Monaliadth

I’ve come back from my North Wales trip to find that all kinds of campaigning has started which focuses on the proposed Dunmaglass Wind Farm. Apparently there is to be a protest as part of next year’s TGO Challenge with Alan Sloman even looking for a coffin!

I’m not a puritan when it comes to wind farms and other forms of renewable energy. Renewable energy has a major role to play in our future energy mix and wind power will be increasingly important. It is now almost 15 years ago that I decided to ensure that my own electricity came from a tariff that was based on renewable production, mostly — in this case — from a major array of turbines sited off the North Wales coast. I honestly can’t understand why most people have not explored such tariffs. Both the current government and its predecessor have committed themselves to a major expansion in wind power.

But new turbine sites have to be planned in a sensitive way with regard to the preservation of what is special about our wild environments and I have to confess to having reservation about this particular scheme.

The Monaliadth is a wonderful area. It is not the highest and most rugged of the highland landscapes but it is nonetheless fascinating and is one of the highlights of any TGO Challenge route that goes through these parts. The wildlife here is fascinating and the long range views stunning. Walk along one of the main ridges here and you’ll be able to see both the mountains of the North West (which you will have walked through) and the Cairngorms. Any existing trek across these hills will reveal a number of existing wind farms but these tend to be away from major tracks and the main ridges. The Dunmaglass proposal would dominate the main ridge that runs from Carn Odhar to Carn Ghriogair.

The proposals sit in classic hiker territory. Many of those crossing this area will have climbed up from Dumnaglass Lodge before either crossing over to the Findhorn or making their way along the main ridge towards Glen Mazaran. If the plans go ahead the long climb up from Dumnaglass and the shooting hut will take the walker through the heart of the wind farm. And once on the ridge walkers will fund their route dominated by large pylons.

Whatever else you think about wind farms the siting of this one is definitely not sensitive to an environment that is special and that should be subject to some kind of protection. It would be true to say that the Monaliadth is not a true wilderness; it is working country. Tracks criss-cross the land in an ever growing web. But to walk on these hills is still to experience a peace and harmony with the natural environment that is all too rare.

I wonder myself whether such plans reflect a problem with Scottish Government policy. Yes the UK needs renewable energy but it does seem as if Scotland sees the export of power as an important plank in the economy of a nation that seeks full independence. In the event of independence Scotland will need to seek maximum advantage from its natural assets and to develop seemingly complimentary sectors such as tourism, although we can see here with the Trump development and the Attadale plans that tourism is not necessarily green and ecologically sound. Balancing the needs of economic development with the natural world is not easy but this Scottish Government seems to have set itself on a path that compromises too much of the natural environment.

This is the wrong plan in the wrong place.

Here are just some of the views that will be effected.

Wide Eyed and High

Monadhliath Mountains

Carn Ghriogair Summit

I’m very fond of the Monaliadth. I’d advise any hiker or TGO Challenger to plot a route that to go through here soon!

 

Arrogance, Ignorance and Greed

Thanks to John Manning for tipping me off about the BBC Scotland documentary (currently on the iplayer) ‘Donald Trump’s Golf War’

This film has been made over a number of years and features interviews and fly-on-the-wall stuff from both the Trump camp and the opposition. It reveals not only the dilemmas of things like this but the attitdes taken by those who are so powerful that they just take it as granted that the things they want will happen, not least because they tend to think that everyone else must be as excited as the project as they are.

The film also shows how the property developer simply can never understand those that are not motivated in money or those that simply value others things more highly. During 12 years as a Councillor in Birmingham I saw this a lot with many different property developers. Trump may seem to a somewhat mad figure but he’s not that unusual.

This programme is still on the iplayer for a few more days and can be downloaded as well if you have the desktop player installed. Really worth watching, a kind of real-life Local Hero but without a happy ending (as yet).

BTW, “Arrogance, Ignorance and Greed” is a song by Steve Knightly of the West Country Band Show of Hands. You can hear an except here. A wonderful band Show of Hands.

Shaping Scottish Landscape

Great new Scottish BBC 1 series I’ve only just discovered. Really worth checking out on the iPlayer!